[Picture of projector]

Laramie Movie Scope:
The Best and Worst Films of 2008

My picks for the top and bottom films of 2008

[Strip of film rule]
by Robert Roten, Film Critic
[strip of film rule]
 

May 10, 2009 -- It is way past time to look back on the year 2008. I skipped most of the bad movies, as usual (sue me) so my “worst of” list is almost non-existent this year, but I've seen most of the best films of last year. Usually, there are six to eight A films (four stars out of four), but this year was an exception. I had 12 films that rate an A. This is strange, because it seemed that several months went by this year when there were no films worth seeing. A lot of my top 10 films were films that were not widely distributed for one reason or another. There are enough A films this year that I'm not going to bother to list B+ films this time (I don't use either A- or A+ in my rating system. That's grade inflation.).

As usual, many of the top films are released in December. I saw a number of these films on screeners (thanks to the studios, publicists and the Online Film Critics Society). The rest, I saw in Laramie, Cheyenne, Fort Collins or Denver. Don't feel left out if you haven't seen all these films. Lots of people haven't seen them all. Most of these are now available on home video. There are some acclaimed films that I haven't yet seen yet myself. Many of these films were poorly distributed around the U.S.

I did see “The Dark Knight” of course, which is probably the film with the most awards that didn't make my top 10 list. It was a good film, but it didn't impress me enough to make my top 10 list. The same is true for the animated film “WALL·E.” It made my top five list for animated films, but not top 10 film overall, as it did on many lists. The other film that bowled most critics over was the documentary film “Man on Wire.” It looks better on a big screen. I saw it first on video, where it put me to sleep repeatedly. The critical love for these three films, “The Dark Knight,” “WALL·E” and “Man on Wire” came as a surprise to me. I didn't think these films were good enough to win any awards, with an exception for the late Heath Ledger's performance as The Joker. He was awesome.

Below the list of top films are a list of honorable mentions, followed by lists of my picks for top director, top actor, top foreign film, etc. Those lists are followed by lists of the worst films, overrated films, funniest, saddest, etc. I've added a couple of Dubious Distinction awards as a satirical comment on certain awards that seem to be based on factors that are literally skin deep. Ordinarily, my top 10 lists include more comedy and films starring black actors. That doesn't seem to be the case this year, except for my inclusion of “Definitely, Maybe” as a top film. I'm sure it won't appear on very many top 10 lists. Drama is easy, but romantic comedy is tough to get right.

Page navigation: Honorable mention Best of by category Funniest movie,   Saddest movie Overrated movies,   Best movies you haven't heard of,   Worst movies, Dubious Distinctions.

Best 10 films of 2008

1. The Visitor[4 stars]

This near-perfect little film puts a different spin on the whole issue of immigration, but it is really about following your heart. Richard Jenkins gives a wonderful performance in this film.

2. The Bank Job [4 stars]

This is a great caper movie about small time hoods who score big, then are hunted by both government agents and underworld thugs. It builds tremendous suspense.

3. Definitely, Maybe[4 stars]

This is the year's best romantic comedy, and that is a very tough genre to perfect. This film has as much heart as it does wit and wisdom.

4. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button[4 stars]

This film seems epic and personal at the same time. It starts out with a beautiful fantasy about a clockmaker and ends with a warmly humanistic tale of life's challenges told from a different perspective.

5. Slumdog Millionaire[4 stars]

A great cross-genre film which uses a TV game show to tell the life story of a young man searching for the love of his life.

6. Frost/Nixon[4 stars]

This film about the famous interviews of Richard Nixon by TV presenter David Frost manages to build a lot of suspense despite the fact that the outcome is well known. A teriffic performance by Frank Langella as Richard Nixon.

7. Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father[4 stars]

This is the year's best documentary. It covers a subject that liberals have a hard time facing: That certain laws written to protect the rights of criminals do so at the expense of innocent victims. This is a story about a terrible injustice.

8. Changeling[4 stars]

This Clint Eastwood movie based on a true story is as powerful as any film released in 2008, but for some reason it wasn't as well received as Eastwood's more popular film, “Gran Torino.” Angelina Jolie stars in this film set during a time in history when women had few rights in America. The performances by Jolie, John Malkovich and Jason Butler Harner are all outstanding.

9. Revolutionary Road[4 stars]

Although Kate Winslet won her award for her role in “The Reader,” in which she appears nude (see Dubious Distinctions below), her best performance was in “Revolutionary Road” as a housewife going crazy during the 1950s in America. Leonardo DiCaprio also gives a powerful performance in this film, based on the great American novel.

10. Bigger, Stronger, Faster: The side effects of being American[4 stars]

This is the second best documentary of the year. It focuses on America's “win at any cost mentality” and the use of performance enhancing drugs in sports, particularly steroids. It hits hard at the hypocrisy in sports and questions the conventional wisdom regarding steroid use. This is a real eye-opener.

Honorable Mention

The Order of Myths[4 stars]

This is the third best documentary of the year. It reveals the Mardi Gras celebration in Mobile, Alabama to be exotic, unexpected, colorful and incredibly ritualized, layered with vast amounts of tradition, denial, submerged racial agendas and hypocrisy. This is a side of America most have never seen.

Synecdoche, New York[4 stars]

This is the most ambitious and challenging film of the year. It might even be the best film of the year. It is so deep it requires multiple viewings to get to the bottom of it and I've only seen it once. It is a fascinating meditation on the nature of the creative mind.

More lists below

[Strip of film rule]

Links to reviews of all the films below are indexed in the following web pages:

A through B   C through D   E through G   H through L
M through Q   R through S   T through Z

Best director

1. Ron Howard -- Frost/Nixon
2. David Fincher -- The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
3. Danny Boyle -- Slumdog Millionaire
4. Sam Mendes -- Revolutionary Road
5. Adam Brooks -- Definitely Maybe

Best actor

1. Mickey Rourke -- The Wrestler
2. Richard Jenkins -- The Visitor
3. Frank Langella -- Frost/Nixon
4. Robert Downey Jr. -- Iron Man
5. Leonardo DiCaprio -- Revolutionary Road

Best actress

1. Sally Hawkins -- Happy-Go-Lucky
2. Kate Winslet -- Revolutionary Road
3. Meryl Streep -- Doubt
4. Angelina Jolie -- Changeling
5. Frances McDormand -- Miss Pettigrew Lives For a Day

Best supporting actor

1. Heath Ledger -- The Dark Knight
2. Philip Seymour Hoffman -- Doubt
3. Robert Downey Jr. -- Tropic Thunder
4. Tom Cruise -- Tropic Thunder
5. Jeff Bridges (-) Iron Man

Best supporting actress

1. Viola Davis (-) Doubt
2. Amy Adams (-) Doubt
3. Amy Adams (-) Miss Pettigrew Lives For a Day
4. Penelope Cruz (-) Vicky Cristina Barcelona
5. Elsa Zylberstein (-) I've Loved You So Long

Best adapted screenplay

1. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (-) Eric Roth
2. Slumdog Millionaire (-) Simon Beaufoy
3. Revolutionary Road (-) Justin Haythe
4. Frost/Nixon (-) Peter Morgan
5. Iron Man (-) Mark Fergus, Hawk Ostby, Art Marcum and Matt Holloway

Best original screenplay

1. The Visitor (-) Thomas McCarthy
2. Definitely, Maybe (-) Adam Brooks
3. Bank Job, The (-) Dick Clement and Ian La Frenais
4. Changeling (-) J. Michael Straczynski
5. In Bruges (-) Martin McDonagh

Best foreign language film

1. I've Loved You So Long
2. The Class
3. 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days
4. Mongol
5. Let the Right One In

Best cinematography

1. Australia
2. Slumdog Millionaire
3. Revolutionary Road
4. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
5. Appaloosa

Best breakthrough performance

1. Jason Butler Harner (-) Changeling
2. Dev Patel (-) Slumdog Millionaire
3. Danai Jekesai Gurira (-) The Visitor
4. Haaz Sleiman (-) The Visitor
5. Brandon Walters (-) Australia

Best breakthrough filmmaker

1. Martin McDonagh (-) In Bruges
2. Philippe Claudel (-) I've Loved You So Long
3. Kurt Kuenne (-) Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father
4. Mark Osborne and John Stevenson (-) Kung Fu Panda
5. Nicholas Stoller (-) Forgetting Sarah Marshall

Best documentary feature

1. Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father
2. Bigger, Stronger, Faster: The Side-Effects of Being American
3. The Order of Myths
4. A Snowmobile For George
5. Young@Heart

Best animated feature

1. Bolt
2. Kung Fu Panda
3. Wall-E
4. Horton Hears a Who
5. The Tale of Despereaux

Best film editing

1. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button - Kirk Baxter and Angus Wall
2. Slumdog Millionaire - Chris Dickens
3. Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father -- Kurt Kuenne
4. Bigger, Stronger, Faster: The Side-Effects of Being American -- Brian Singbiel
5. Changeling (-) Joel Cox and Gary Roach

Best original musical score

1. Australia (-) David Hirschfelder
2. Appaloosa (-) Jeff Beal
3. Alexandre Desplat – The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
4. Clint Eastwood – Changeling
5. Danny Elfman – Milk

Links to reviews of all films on this site are indexed below:

A through B   C through D   E through G   H through L
M through Q   R through S   T through Z

Funniest film of the year

Get Smart[3 stars]

Saddest film of the year

Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father

The year's most overrated films

The Dark Knight[3 stars]
WALL·E[3 stars]
Man on Wire[3 stars]
Wendy and Lucy[2 stars]
A Christmas Tale[3 stars]
Happy-Go-Lucky[3 stars]
Hunger[3 stars]

The year's best films you've never heard of

The Visitor[4 stars]
The Bank Job [4 stars]
Definitely, Maybe[4 stars]
Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father[4 stars]
Revolutionary Road[4 stars]
Bigger, Stronger, Faster: The side effects of being American[4 stars]
The Order of Myths[4 stars]
Synecdoche, New York[4 stars]
I've Loved You So Long (Il y a longtemps que je t'aime)[3.5 stars]
A Snowmobile For George[3.5 stars]
The Great Debaters[3.5 stars]
The Class[3.5 stars]
4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days
(4 luni, 3 saptamâni si 2 zile)
[3 stars]
Ghost Town[3 stars]

The Worst Films of 2008

While I saw most of the best films of the year, I purposefully missed nearly all of the worst films, including The Hottie and the Nottie, Harold, Meet the Spartans, Strange Wilderness, College, In the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale, Surfer, Dude, Witless Protection, Prom Night, 88 Minutes, Saw V, An American Carol, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, House of the Sleeping Beauties, Take, Postal, Disaster Movie, Repo! The Genetic Opera, The Love Guru, Towelhead, Meet Dave, among many others, so this is not in any way a list of the worst of the worst films, just the worst of the films I saw. After all, I don't get into the movies for free, and I don't like to waste my money, but I got fooled into watching the following films anyway:

The House Bunny[2 stars]
Wendy and Lucy[2 stars]

Dubious Distinctions

The honorary Roman Polanski Juicy Jailbait Award, also known as the “Breakthrough Actor” award or the “Newcomer” award (insert Beavis and Butthead snickering here) is the first dubious distinction. The second dubious distinction is the Marilyn Chambers Memorial Nudity Award.

The jailbait award is usually won by very attractive, very young women, or girls, some of whom are prepubescent, or at who least look like they might be. Why is this you ask? Because most film critics are men and most men (especially older men) have trouble remembering actors at the end of the year for awards purposes unless they are very young and pretty. O.K., so they are dirty old men.

Past winners are Saoirse Ronan for “Atonement,” Anna Paquin for “The Piano,” Ziyi Zhang for “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon,” of course Polanski's old flame, Natasha Kinski for “Tess” and most of the cast of “Thirteen.”

The award this year goes to Lina Leandersson for “Let the Right One In” (Låt den rätte komma in). She is very pretty and plays the part of a 12-year-old vampire. She also appears partially nude in the film and there is even a brief image of her vagina (unless that shot was of some sort of vagina double) in the film. No contest! We've got a winner!

The second dubious distinction is the Marilyn Chambers Memorial Nudity Award (If I have to take my clothes off to win an award, then so be it):

Kate Winslet wins the 2008 nudity award for her naked performance in “The Reader.” Winslet is a fine actress and she shouldn't have to take off all her clothes to win an Oscar, but that is what it took to get past the competition. She was even better in “Revolutionary Road,” but kept her clothes on in that film, and consequently didn't even get an Oscar nomination for her great performance. She did, however, win a Golden Globe award for her performance in “Revolutionary Road.” Apparently European voters are more jaded about nudity, and can look past it to see the performance underneath, as it were. Past winners of the nudity award are, Rinko Kikuchi for “Babel,” Maria Bello for “A History of Violence” and Kristen Scott Thomas for “The English Patient.”

These are the kinds of awards that guys just never win for some reason.

Links to reviews of all the films are indexed below:

A through B   C through D   E through G   H through I
J through L   M through N   O through Q   R through S   T through Z

Page navigation: Honorable mention Best of by category Funniest movie,   Saddest movie Overrated movies Best movies you haven't heard of,   Worst movies, Dubious Distinctions.

[strip of film rule]
Copyright © 2008 Robert Roten. All rights reserved.
Reproduced with the permission of the copyright holder.
[strip of film rule]
 
Back to the Laramie Movie Scope index.
 
[Rule made of Seventh Seal sillouettes]

Robert Roten can be reached via e-mail at my last name at lariat dot org. [Mailer button: image of letter and envelope]